Who owns Hong Kong?

Alia | October 1st, 2014 - 7:24 pm

All eyes are on the pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong, which, many argued, will have profound implications for world economy, China’s economy, and most importantly, for China’s overall democratic progress, however it may end. But will it?

APTOPIX Hong Kong Democracy ProtestThe protests’ economic effect is hard to assess right now, but there seems to be enough hints to conclude whether the “Umbrella Revolution” is a big enough threat for Beijing to fear, and whether it is likely to light the fuse to blast democracy quests into the rest of China.

One often missing but key analysis is how China’s 1.3 billion mainlanders think about Hong Kong and what’s happening there right now. Sentiment among mainlanders is directly related to whether they will echo Hong Kong’s cry, and how much they will support their government if Beijing decides to play tough.

Below is a rough translation of a viral analysis of situations in Hong Kong that has been widely shared on both Wechat, China’s most popular messaging tool, and Weibo, China’s leading social media platform. The article, titled “Who Owns Hong Kong”,  is a good read into how mainlanders are making sense of Hong Kong’s unrest.

What has the mother country done for Hong Kong?

  • In terms of politics, China has honored its commitment to the policy of one country, two systems.  Hong Kong’s status as a special administrative region has never changed. Laws effective in all parts of mainland China has never been pushed in Hong Kong who got to keep its own legal system.
  • In terms of public finance, Hong Kong doesn’t need to pay a single penny of tax to the central government. Money out of Hong Kong is used on Hong Kong’s own development. Other parts of China, no matter how poor, won’t bother Hong Kong at all. An envy for big tax payers like the neighboring province of Guangdong.
  • In terms of development protection, in order to keep Hong Kong’s historical advantage as a hub of internal finances, China has suppressed development in competing cities in mainland, such as Shanghai.
  • In terms of trade, 273 major product categories from Hong Kong are exempt from import taxes, meaning that mainland’s huge market is entirely open to Hong Kong. A special treatment that surrounding countries would kill to get.
  • In terms of tourism, China has encouraged trips to Hong Kong, making it such a hot spot for mainland tourists who spend hard to help with Hong Kong’s economy.
  • In terms of economic support, China is the strongest support behind Hong Kong for it to weather through recession and into sustainable development.
  • In terms of people’s livelihood, Hong Kong is a small region with fairly no agriculture. Tons of best-quality foods are sent to Hong Kong from mainland every day, plus cheap resources like water, gas and electricity.
  • In terms of respect, Hong Kong is given a high degree of respect on international stage. It’s allowed to present itself independently in international affairs such as economic alliances and global sports.

The article further listed what Hong Kong has done to China, including rallies for independence, preference of colonial rule, and discrimination over mainlanders, etc. As sad as it may seem, the article does represent how many Chinese mainlanders think about protesters in Hong Kong – a groups of spoiled and unappreciative whiners who complain too much while already enjoying many privileges.

Certainly, there is a considerable number of people who fully support the protesters in Hong Kong. But most Chinese couldn’t care less about Hong Kong and whether people there enjoy true democracy. To them, it never felt like “one country, two systems,” but rather “two countries, two systems.”  Chinese citizens need to apply for a special permit (like a visa) before visiting Hong Kong that only lasts a short period of time. Even foreigners enjoy a longer period of visa-free stay in Hong Kong than Chinese.

Others who do care are more likely to side with the Chinese government than with Hong Kong protesters. To say that the people from mainland and Hong Kong dislike each other is an understatement. The whole “locust” campaign was not nice at all, and not surprisingly mainlanders are pissed. The result is little sympathy with Hong Kong protesters. What’s worse, many actually think that Beijing should take a hardline approach, as many of them suggested: “So much with “one country, two systems.’ Simply make it one country and take away Hong Kong’s many special treatments!”

The only thing that everybody agrees with is: “One country, two systems” did not and will not work. 

Related posts:

Dishwasher at a five-star restaurant in Nanjing fired for taking home leftovers
Kai-Fu Lee: "What A Wonder404 World"
The love affair that everybody is talking about
Modern China's first open war over freedom of speech accelerated
Chinese mom urged her son to go home for Spring Festival…on an Australian newspaper
Will China’s “mass culture” make a left turn?

5 Responses to “Who owns Hong Kong?”

  1. cs:go says:

    Wonderful website you have in here

  2. Good site you’ve in here

  3. site says:

    I even have an idea for construction of a new facility to replace that evil place known as Gitmo (this is very important
    because we don’t want to create a bad impression in the minds of our fellow members in the United Nations).

    Try to use large bags; it will be easier to cut smaller shapes out of larger
    pieces than add two pieces together. With the new Jelly Bean, you will be able to expand notifications and get a preview
    on the recent e-mail message.

    I like it when people get together and share thoughts.
    Great site, continue the good work!

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply to site